Liberal Bill Aims to Regulate Labour Code Amid Ongoing Legal Battles

The Liberal administration is putting forward proposals aimed at creating a “guardrail” around a contentious aspect of the Labour Code. However, experts contend that even if the bill is enacted as it stands, legal disputes will continue unabated.

For many years, Section 107 has granted the minister in charge extensive authority to “maintain or secure industrial peace.” Since 2024, the federal government has faced criticism for invoking this section to compel striking workers to return to work and initiate binding arbitration.

Most recently, Labour Minister Patty Hajdu exercised this provision to direct Air Canada flight attendants back to their duties last summer. Ultimately, however, the union defied the order, leading to a tentative agreement being struck shortly thereafter.

The Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE), representing Air Canada flight attendants, has initiated several court challenges against the government’s application of Section 107, including one that questions the constitutionality of this portion of the Labour Code.

WATCH | Labour minister says new bill adds ‘guardrail’ around Section 107:

Building Canada Strong Act will ‘put a guardrail’ around Labour Code provisions, says Hajdu

September 21|

Duration

1:28

In response to a reporter who suggested that changes to the Canada Labour Code in the omnibus bill tabled by the government Monday will weaken the right to strike, Jobs and Families Minister Patty Hajdu says the bill will ‘raise the bar around accountability’ on both sides of negotiations.

Andrea Talarico, a law professor at the University of Ottawa who focuses on labor law, noted that even if the government attempts to redefine Section 107, the issue of whether it can infringe upon the right to strike will “certainly” be addressed by the Supreme Court.

“Given the significant controversy that impacts Charter rights during these economically challenging times, this matter must reach the Supreme Court for clarity,” she stated.

On Monday, the government unveiled Bill C-39, an omnibus bill that proposes alterations to the application of Section 107. If approved, the minister would need to declare that a strike is negatively impacting the “national interest” and must consider a report from a newly appointed mediator responsible for outlining the positions of both parties.

Prime Minister Mark Carney asserted on Tuesday that the bill “definitely strengthens the right to strike.”

However, the Canadian Labour Congress (CLC) condemned the proposed changes even before the bill was officially introduced.

WATCH | Canadian Labour Congress says Ottawa must not restrict right to strike:

Any new restrictions on right to strike are ‘unacceptable’: Canadian Labour Congress

September 22|

Duration

0:46

Speaking to reporters about the new Liberal major projects bill, Canadian Labour Congress president Bea Bruske says while Canada’s workers want to help in the U.S. trade war, ‘we cannot have our elbow up against Trump with our hands tied behind our backs at bargaining tables.’

Mark Rowlinson, a lawyer affiliated with the CLC, informed reporters on Tuesday that the new legislation represents “the clearest possible violation” of the Charter and that it “circumvents” existing court challenges related to Section 107.

Nonetheless, CLC president Bea Bruske mentioned that the organization is still considering its options regarding a potential legal challenge against the new law.

Brian Gottheil, a human resources consultant and attorney, shared with CBC News that if the new law is enacted, the government might argue that ongoing court challenges have become “moot” and are no longer pertinent.

“I anticipate that the government will assert that since they have amended Section 107 and the issues being contested in prior cases no longer exist, they will claim that this matter is moot and those cases should be dismissed,” he explained.

Gottheil indicated that the courts might consider that argument in situations where unions contest specific instances of Section 107 being invoked to end a strike. However, he believes that cases challenging the law based on Charter grounds will likely proceed.

“Canadians possess a constitutional right to freedom of association. The Supreme Court has interpreted this to encompass the right to collective bargaining and the right to strike,” he added.

“The critical question is whether granting the minister an open-ended authority to instruct the federal labor board to terminate strikes and lockouts infringes upon the Constitution. I believe this new legislation continues to keep that issue alive.”

The Teamsters union initiated its own legal proceedings after the government applied Section 107 to end a rail workers strike in 2024. Since the union is seeking damages, Talarico noted that the government’s mootness argument might not hold water.

“The courts need to assess what occurred with the unions and whether damages can be awarded,” she remarked.

The Labour Code applies solely to federally regulated sectors, which include airlines, banks, ports, and railways. However, Talarico argued that provincial governments are likely observing how the dispute regarding Section 107 unfolds.